Source code for aerosandbox.aerodynamics.aero_3D.vortex_lattice_method

import aerosandbox.numpy as np
from aerosandbox import ExplicitAnalysis
from aerosandbox.geometry import *
from aerosandbox.performance import OperatingPoint
from aerosandbox.aerodynamics.aero_3D.singularities.uniform_strength_horseshoe_singularities import \
    calculate_induced_velocity_horseshoe
from typing import Dict, Any, List, Callable
import copy


### Define some helper functions that take a vector and make it a Nx1 or 1xN, respectively.
# Useful for broadcasting with matrices later.
[docs]def tall(array): return np.reshape(array, (-1, 1))
[docs]def wide(array): return np.reshape(array, (1, -1))
[docs]class VortexLatticeMethod(ExplicitAnalysis): """ An explicit (linear) vortex-lattice-method aerodynamics analysis. Usage example: >>> analysis = asb.VortexLatticeMethod( >>> airplane=my_airplane, >>> op_point=asb.OperatingPoint( >>> velocity=100, # m/s >>> alpha=5, # deg >>> beta=4, # deg >>> p=0.01, # rad/sec >>> q=0.02, # rad/sec >>> r=0.03, # rad/sec >>> ) >>> ) >>> aero_data = analysis.run() >>> analysis.draw() """ def __init__(self, airplane: Airplane, op_point: OperatingPoint, xyz_ref: List[float] = None, run_symmetric_if_possible: bool = False, verbose: bool = False, spanwise_resolution: int = 10, spanwise_spacing_function: Callable[[float, float, float], np.ndarray] = np.cosspace, chordwise_resolution: int = 10, chordwise_spacing_function: Callable[[float, float, float], np.ndarray] = np.cosspace, vortex_core_radius: float = 1e-8, align_trailing_vortices_with_wind: bool = False, ): super().__init__() ### Set defaults if xyz_ref is None: xyz_ref = airplane.xyz_ref ### Initialize self.airplane = airplane self.op_point = op_point self.xyz_ref = xyz_ref self.verbose = verbose self.spanwise_resolution = spanwise_resolution self.spanwise_spacing_function = spanwise_spacing_function self.chordwise_resolution = chordwise_resolution self.chordwise_spacing_function = chordwise_spacing_function self.vortex_core_radius = vortex_core_radius self.align_trailing_vortices_with_wind = align_trailing_vortices_with_wind ### Determine whether you should run the problem as symmetric self.run_symmetric = False if run_symmetric_if_possible: raise NotImplementedError("VLM with symmetry detection not yet implemented!") # try: # self.run_symmetric = ( # Satisfies assumptions # self.op_point.beta == 0 and # self.op_point.p == 0 and # self.op_point.r == 0 and # self.airplane.is_entirely_symmetric() # ) # except RuntimeError: # Required because beta, p, r, etc. may be non-numeric (e.g. opti variables) # pass
[docs] def __repr__(self): return self.__class__.__name__ + "(\n\t" + "\n\t".join([ f"airplane={self.airplane}", f"op_point={self.op_point}", f"xyz_ref={self.xyz_ref}", ]) + "\n)"
[docs] def run(self) -> Dict[str, Any]: """ Computes the aerodynamic forces. Returns a dictionary with keys: - 'F_g' : an [x, y, z] list of forces in geometry axes [N] - 'F_b' : an [x, y, z] list of forces in body axes [N] - 'F_w' : an [x, y, z] list of forces in wind axes [N] - 'M_g' : an [x, y, z] list of moments about geometry axes [Nm] - 'M_b' : an [x, y, z] list of moments about body axes [Nm] - 'M_w' : an [x, y, z] list of moments about wind axes [Nm] - 'L' : the lift force [N]. Definitionally, this is in wind axes. - 'Y' : the side force [N]. This is in wind axes. - 'D' : the drag force [N]. Definitionally, this is in wind axes. - 'l_b', the rolling moment, in body axes [Nm]. Positive is roll-right. - 'm_b', the pitching moment, in body axes [Nm]. Positive is pitch-up. - 'n_b', the yawing moment, in body axes [Nm]. Positive is nose-right. - 'CL', the lift coefficient [-]. Definitionally, this is in wind axes. - 'CY', the sideforce coefficient [-]. This is in wind axes. - 'CD', the drag coefficient [-]. Definitionally, this is in wind axes. - 'Cl', the rolling coefficient [-], in body axes - 'Cm', the pitching coefficient [-], in body axes - 'Cn', the yawing coefficient [-], in body axes Nondimensional values are nondimensionalized using reference values in the VortexLatticeMethod.airplane object. """ if self.verbose: print("Meshing...") ##### Make Panels front_left_vertices = [] back_left_vertices = [] back_right_vertices = [] front_right_vertices = [] is_trailing_edge = [] for wing in self.airplane.wings: if self.spanwise_resolution > 1: wing = wing.subdivide_sections( ratio=self.spanwise_resolution, spacing_function=self.spanwise_spacing_function ) points, faces = wing.mesh_thin_surface( method="quad", chordwise_resolution=self.chordwise_resolution, chordwise_spacing_function=self.chordwise_spacing_function, add_camber=True ) front_left_vertices.append(points[faces[:, 0], :]) back_left_vertices.append(points[faces[:, 1], :]) back_right_vertices.append(points[faces[:, 2], :]) front_right_vertices.append(points[faces[:, 3], :]) is_trailing_edge.append( (np.arange(len(faces)) + 1) % self.chordwise_resolution == 0 ) front_left_vertices = np.concatenate(front_left_vertices) back_left_vertices = np.concatenate(back_left_vertices) back_right_vertices = np.concatenate(back_right_vertices) front_right_vertices = np.concatenate(front_right_vertices) is_trailing_edge = np.concatenate(is_trailing_edge) ### Compute panel statistics diag1 = front_right_vertices - back_left_vertices diag2 = front_left_vertices - back_right_vertices cross = np.cross(diag1, diag2) cross_norm = np.linalg.norm(cross, axis=1) normal_directions = cross / tall(cross_norm) areas = cross_norm / 2 # Compute the location of points of interest on each panel left_vortex_vertices = 0.75 * front_left_vertices + 0.25 * back_left_vertices right_vortex_vertices = 0.75 * front_right_vertices + 0.25 * back_right_vertices vortex_centers = (left_vortex_vertices + right_vortex_vertices) / 2 vortex_bound_leg = right_vortex_vertices - left_vortex_vertices collocation_points = ( 0.5 * (0.25 * front_left_vertices + 0.75 * back_left_vertices) + 0.5 * (0.25 * front_right_vertices + 0.75 * back_right_vertices) ) ### Save things to the instance for later access self.front_left_vertices = front_left_vertices self.back_left_vertices = back_left_vertices self.back_right_vertices = back_right_vertices self.front_right_vertices = front_right_vertices self.is_trailing_edge = is_trailing_edge self.normal_directions = normal_directions self.areas = areas self.left_vortex_vertices = left_vortex_vertices self.right_vortex_vertices = right_vortex_vertices self.vortex_centers = vortex_centers self.vortex_bound_leg = vortex_bound_leg self.collocation_points = collocation_points ##### Setup Operating Point if self.verbose: print("Calculating the freestream influence...") steady_freestream_velocity = self.op_point.compute_freestream_velocity_geometry_axes() # Direction the wind is GOING TO, in geometry axes coordinates steady_freestream_direction = steady_freestream_velocity / np.linalg.norm(steady_freestream_velocity) rotation_freestream_velocities = self.op_point.compute_rotation_velocity_geometry_axes( collocation_points) freestream_velocities = np.add(wide(steady_freestream_velocity), rotation_freestream_velocities) # Nx3, represents the freestream velocity at each panel collocation point (c) freestream_influences = np.sum(freestream_velocities * normal_directions, axis=1) ### Save things to the instance for later access self.steady_freestream_velocity = steady_freestream_velocity self.steady_freestream_direction = steady_freestream_direction self.freestream_velocities = freestream_velocities ##### Setup Geometry ### Calculate AIC matrix if self.verbose: print("Calculating the collocation influence matrix...") u_collocations_unit, v_collocations_unit, w_collocations_unit = calculate_induced_velocity_horseshoe( x_field=tall(collocation_points[:, 0]), y_field=tall(collocation_points[:, 1]), z_field=tall(collocation_points[:, 2]), x_left=wide(left_vortex_vertices[:, 0]), y_left=wide(left_vortex_vertices[:, 1]), z_left=wide(left_vortex_vertices[:, 2]), x_right=wide(right_vortex_vertices[:, 0]), y_right=wide(right_vortex_vertices[:, 1]), z_right=wide(right_vortex_vertices[:, 2]), trailing_vortex_direction=( steady_freestream_direction if self.align_trailing_vortices_with_wind else np.array([1, 0, 0]) ), gamma=1., vortex_core_radius=self.vortex_core_radius ) AIC = ( u_collocations_unit * tall(normal_directions[:, 0]) + v_collocations_unit * tall(normal_directions[:, 1]) + w_collocations_unit * tall(normal_directions[:, 2]) ) ##### Calculate Vortex Strengths if self.verbose: print("Calculating vortex strengths...") self.vortex_strengths = np.linalg.solve(AIC, -freestream_influences) ##### Calculate forces ### Calculate Near-Field Forces and Moments # Governing Equation: The force on a straight, small vortex filament is F = rho * cross(V, l) * gamma, # where rho is density, V is the velocity vector, cross() is the cross product operator, # l is the vector of the filament itself, and gamma is the circulation. if self.verbose: print("Calculating forces on each panel...") # Calculate the induced velocity at the center of each bound leg V_centers = self.get_velocity_at_points(vortex_centers) # Calculate forces_inviscid_geometry, the force on the ith panel. Note that this is in GEOMETRY AXES, # not WIND AXES or BODY AXES. Vi_cross_li = np.cross(V_centers, vortex_bound_leg, axis=1) forces_geometry = self.op_point.atmosphere.density() * Vi_cross_li * tall(self.vortex_strengths) moments_geometry = np.cross( np.add(vortex_centers, -wide(np.array(self.xyz_ref))), forces_geometry ) # Calculate total forces and moments force_geometry = np.sum(forces_geometry, axis=0) moment_geometry = np.sum(moments_geometry, axis=0) force_body = self.op_point.convert_axes( force_geometry[0], force_geometry[1], force_geometry[2], from_axes="geometry", to_axes="body" ) force_wind = self.op_point.convert_axes( force_body[0], force_body[1], force_body[2], from_axes="body", to_axes="wind" ) moment_body = self.op_point.convert_axes( moment_geometry[0], moment_geometry[1], moment_geometry[2], from_axes="geometry", to_axes="body" ) moment_wind = self.op_point.convert_axes( moment_body[0], moment_body[1], moment_body[2], from_axes="body", to_axes="wind" ) ### Save things to the instance for later access self.forces_geometry = forces_geometry self.moments_geometry = moments_geometry self.force_geometry = force_geometry self.force_body = force_body self.force_wind = force_wind self.moment_geometry = moment_geometry self.moment_body = moment_body self.moment_wind = moment_wind # Calculate dimensional forces L = -force_wind[2] D = -force_wind[0] Y = force_wind[1] l_b = moment_body[0] m_b = moment_body[1] n_b = moment_body[2] # Calculate nondimensional forces q = self.op_point.dynamic_pressure() s_ref = self.airplane.s_ref b_ref = self.airplane.b_ref c_ref = self.airplane.c_ref CL = L / q / s_ref CD = D / q / s_ref CY = Y / q / s_ref Cl = l_b / q / s_ref / b_ref Cm = m_b / q / s_ref / c_ref Cn = n_b / q / s_ref / b_ref return { "F_g": force_geometry, "F_b": force_body, "F_w": force_wind, "M_g": moment_geometry, "M_b": moment_body, "M_w": moment_wind, "L" : L, "D" : D, "Y" : Y, "l_b": l_b, "m_b": m_b, "n_b": n_b, "CL" : CL, "CD" : CD, "CY" : CY, "Cl" : Cl, "Cm" : Cm, "Cn" : Cn, }
[docs] def run_with_stability_derivatives(self, alpha=True, beta=True, p=True, q=True, r=True, ): """ Computes the aerodynamic forces and moments on the airplane, and the stability derivatives. Arguments essentially determine which stability derivatives are computed. If a stability derivative is not needed, leaving it False will speed up the computation. Args: - alpha (bool): If True, compute the stability derivatives with respect to the angle of attack (alpha). - beta (bool): If True, compute the stability derivatives with respect to the sideslip angle (beta). - p (bool): If True, compute the stability derivatives with respect to the body-axis roll rate (p). - q (bool): If True, compute the stability derivatives with respect to the body-axis pitch rate (q). - r (bool): If True, compute the stability derivatives with respect to the body-axis yaw rate (r). Returns: a dictionary with keys: - 'F_g' : an [x, y, z] list of forces in geometry axes [N] - 'F_b' : an [x, y, z] list of forces in body axes [N] - 'F_w' : an [x, y, z] list of forces in wind axes [N] - 'M_g' : an [x, y, z] list of moments about geometry axes [Nm] - 'M_b' : an [x, y, z] list of moments about body axes [Nm] - 'M_w' : an [x, y, z] list of moments about wind axes [Nm] - 'L' : the lift force [N]. Definitionally, this is in wind axes. - 'Y' : the side force [N]. This is in wind axes. - 'D' : the drag force [N]. Definitionally, this is in wind axes. - 'l_b', the rolling moment, in body axes [Nm]. Positive is roll-right. - 'm_b', the pitching moment, in body axes [Nm]. Positive is pitch-up. - 'n_b', the yawing moment, in body axes [Nm]. Positive is nose-right. - 'CL', the lift coefficient [-]. Definitionally, this is in wind axes. - 'CY', the sideforce coefficient [-]. This is in wind axes. - 'CD', the drag coefficient [-]. Definitionally, this is in wind axes. - 'Cl', the rolling coefficient [-], in body axes - 'Cm', the pitching coefficient [-], in body axes - 'Cn', the yawing coefficient [-], in body axes Along with additional keys, depending on the value of the `alpha`, `beta`, `p`, `q`, and `r` arguments. For example, if `alpha=True`, then the following additional keys will be present: - 'CLa', the lift coefficient derivative with respect to alpha [1/rad] - 'CDa', the drag coefficient derivative with respect to alpha [1/rad] - 'CYa', the sideforce coefficient derivative with respect to alpha [1/rad] - 'Cla', the rolling moment coefficient derivative with respect to alpha [1/rad] - 'Cma', the pitching moment coefficient derivative with respect to alpha [1/rad] - 'Cna', the yawing moment coefficient derivative with respect to alpha [1/rad] - 'x_np', the neutral point location in the x direction [m] Nondimensional values are nondimensionalized using reference values in the VortexLatticeMethod.airplane object. Data types: - The "L", "Y", "D", "l_b", "m_b", "n_b", "CL", "CY", "CD", "Cl", "Cm", and "Cn" keys are: - floats if the OperatingPoint object is not vectorized (i.e., if all attributes of OperatingPoint are floats, not arrays). - arrays if the OperatingPoint object is vectorized (i.e., if any attribute of OperatingPoint is an array). - The "F_g", "F_b", "F_w", "M_g", "M_b", and "M_w" keys are always lists, which will contain either floats or arrays, again depending on whether the OperatingPoint object is vectorized or not. """ abbreviations = { "alpha": "a", "beta" : "b", "p" : "p", "q" : "q", "r" : "r", } finite_difference_amounts = { "alpha": 0.001, "beta" : 0.001, "p" : 0.001 * (2 * self.op_point.velocity) / self.airplane.b_ref, "q" : 0.001 * (2 * self.op_point.velocity) / self.airplane.c_ref, "r" : 0.001 * (2 * self.op_point.velocity) / self.airplane.b_ref, } scaling_factors = { "alpha": np.degrees(1), "beta" : np.degrees(1), "p" : (2 * self.op_point.velocity) / self.airplane.b_ref, "q" : (2 * self.op_point.velocity) / self.airplane.c_ref, "r" : (2 * self.op_point.velocity) / self.airplane.b_ref, } original_op_point = self.op_point # Compute the point analysis, which returns a dictionary that we will later add key:value pairs to. run_base = self.run() # Note for the loops below: here, "derivative numerator" and "... denominator" refer to the quantity being # differentiated and the variable of differentiation, respectively. In other words, in the expression df/dx, # the "numerator" is f, and the "denominator" is x. I realize that this would make a mathematician cry (as a # partial derivative is not a fraction), but the reality is that there seems to be no commonly-accepted name # for these terms. (Curiously, this contrasts with integration, where there is an "integrand" and a "variable # of integration".) for derivative_denominator in abbreviations.keys(): if not locals()[derivative_denominator]: # Basically, if the parameter from the function input is not True, continue # Skip this run. # This way, you can (optionally) speed up this routine if you only need static derivatives, # or longitudinal derivatives, etc. # These lines make a copy of the original operating point, incremented by the finite difference amount # along the variable defined by derivative_denominator. incremented_op_point = copy.copy(original_op_point) incremented_op_point.__setattr__( derivative_denominator, original_op_point.__getattribute__(derivative_denominator) + finite_difference_amounts[ derivative_denominator] ) vlm_incremented = copy.copy(self) vlm_incremented.op_point = incremented_op_point run_incremented = vlm_incremented.run() for derivative_numerator in [ "CL", "CD", "CY", "Cl", "Cm", "Cn", ]: derivative_name = derivative_numerator + abbreviations[derivative_denominator] # Gives "CLa" run_base[derivative_name] = ( ( # Finite-difference out the derivatives run_incremented[derivative_numerator] - run_base[ derivative_numerator] ) / finite_difference_amounts[derivative_denominator] * scaling_factors[derivative_denominator] ) ### Try to compute and append neutral point, if possible if derivative_denominator == "alpha": run_base["x_np"] = self.xyz_ref[0] - ( run_base["Cma"] * (self.airplane.c_ref / run_base["CLa"]) ) if derivative_denominator == "beta": run_base["x_np_lateral"] = self.xyz_ref[0] - ( run_base["Cnb"] * (self.airplane.b_ref / run_base["CYb"]) ) return run_base
[docs] def get_induced_velocity_at_points(self, points: np.ndarray, ) -> np.ndarray: """ Computes the induced velocity at a set of points in the flowfield. Args: points: A Nx3 array of points that you would like to know the induced velocities at. Given in geometry axes. Returns: A Nx3 of the induced velocity at those points. Given in geometry axes. """ u_induced, v_induced, w_induced = calculate_induced_velocity_horseshoe( x_field=tall(points[:, 0]), y_field=tall(points[:, 1]), z_field=tall(points[:, 2]), x_left=wide(self.left_vortex_vertices[:, 0]), y_left=wide(self.left_vortex_vertices[:, 1]), z_left=wide(self.left_vortex_vertices[:, 2]), x_right=wide(self.right_vortex_vertices[:, 0]), y_right=wide(self.right_vortex_vertices[:, 1]), z_right=wide(self.right_vortex_vertices[:, 2]), trailing_vortex_direction=self.steady_freestream_direction if self.align_trailing_vortices_with_wind else np.array( [1, 0, 0]), gamma=wide(self.vortex_strengths), vortex_core_radius=self.vortex_core_radius ) u_induced = np.sum(u_induced, axis=1) v_induced = np.sum(v_induced, axis=1) w_induced = np.sum(w_induced, axis=1) V_induced = np.stack([ u_induced, v_induced, w_induced ], axis=1) return V_induced
[docs] def get_velocity_at_points(self, points: np.ndarray ) -> np.ndarray: """ Computes the velocity at a set of points in the flowfield. Args: points: A Nx3 array of points that you would like to know the velocities at. Given in geometry axes. Returns: A Nx3 of the velocity at those points. Given in geometry axes. """ V_induced = self.get_induced_velocity_at_points(points) rotation_freestream_velocities = self.op_point.compute_rotation_velocity_geometry_axes( points ) freestream_velocities = np.add(wide(self.steady_freestream_velocity), rotation_freestream_velocities) V = V_induced + freestream_velocities return V
[docs] def calculate_streamlines(self, seed_points: np.ndarray = None, n_steps: int = 300, length: float = None, ) -> np.ndarray: """ Computes streamlines, starting at specific seed points. After running this function, a new instance variable `VortexLatticeFilaments.streamlines` is computed Uses simple forward-Euler integration with a fixed spatial stepsize (i.e., velocity vectors are normalized before ODE integration). After investigation, it's not worth doing fancier ODE integration methods (adaptive schemes, RK substepping, etc.), due to the near-singular conditions near vortex filaments. Args: seed_points: A Nx3 ndarray that contains a list of points where streamlines are started. Will be auto-calculated if not specified. n_steps: The number of individual streamline steps to trace. Minimum of 2. length: The approximate total length of the streamlines desired, in meters. Will be auto-calculated if not specified. Returns: streamlines: a 3D array with dimensions: (n_seed_points) x (3) x (n_steps). Consists of streamlines data. Result is also saved as an instance variable, VortexLatticeMethod.streamlines. """ if self.verbose: print("Calculating streamlines...") if length is None: length = self.airplane.c_ref * 5 if seed_points is None: left_TE_vertices = self.back_left_vertices[self.is_trailing_edge.astype(bool)] right_TE_vertices = self.back_right_vertices[self.is_trailing_edge.astype(bool)] N_streamlines_target = 200 seed_points_per_panel = np.maximum(1, N_streamlines_target // len(left_TE_vertices)) nondim_node_locations = np.linspace(0, 1, seed_points_per_panel + 1) nondim_seed_locations = (nondim_node_locations[1:] + nondim_node_locations[:-1]) / 2 seed_points = np.concatenate([ x * left_TE_vertices + (1 - x) * right_TE_vertices for x in nondim_seed_locations ]) streamlines = np.empty((len(seed_points), 3, n_steps)) streamlines[:, :, 0] = seed_points for i in range(1, n_steps): V = self.get_velocity_at_points(streamlines[:, :, i - 1]) streamlines[:, :, i] = ( streamlines[:, :, i - 1] + length / n_steps * V / tall(np.linalg.norm(V, axis=1)) ) self.streamlines = streamlines if self.verbose: print("Streamlines calculated.") return streamlines
[docs] def draw(self, c: np.ndarray = None, cmap: str = None, colorbar_label: str = None, show: bool = True, show_kwargs: Dict = None, draw_streamlines=True, recalculate_streamlines=False, backend: str = "pyvista" ): """ Draws the solution. Note: Must be called on a SOLVED AeroProblem object. To solve an AeroProblem, use opti.solve(). To substitute a solved solution, use ap = sol(ap). :return: """ if show_kwargs is None: show_kwargs = {} if c is None: c = self.vortex_strengths colorbar_label = "Vortex Strengths" if draw_streamlines: if (not hasattr(self, 'streamlines')) or recalculate_streamlines: self.calculate_streamlines() if backend == "plotly": from aerosandbox.visualization.plotly_Figure3D import Figure3D fig = Figure3D() for i in range(len(self.front_left_vertices)): fig.add_quad( points=[ self.front_left_vertices[i, :], self.back_left_vertices[i, :], self.back_right_vertices[i, :], self.front_right_vertices[i, :], ], intensity=c[i], outline=True, ) if draw_streamlines: for i in range(self.streamlines.shape[0]): fig.add_streamline(self.streamlines[i, :, :].T) return fig.draw( show=show, colorbar_title=colorbar_label, **show_kwargs, ) elif backend == "pyvista": import pyvista as pv plotter = pv.Plotter() plotter.title = "ASB VortexLatticeMethod" plotter.add_axes() plotter.show_grid(color='gray') ### Draw the airplane mesh points = np.concatenate([ self.front_left_vertices, self.back_left_vertices, self.back_right_vertices, self.front_right_vertices ]) N = len(self.front_left_vertices) range_N = np.arange(N) faces = tall(range_N) + wide(np.array([0, 1, 2, 3]) * N) mesh = pv.PolyData( *mesh_utils.convert_mesh_to_polydata_format(points, faces) ) scalar_bar_args = {} if colorbar_label is not None: scalar_bar_args["title"] = colorbar_label plotter.add_mesh( mesh=mesh, scalars=c, show_edges=True, show_scalar_bar=c is not None, scalar_bar_args=scalar_bar_args, cmap=cmap, ) ### Draw the streamlines if draw_streamlines: import aerosandbox.tools.pretty_plots as p for i in range(self.streamlines.shape[0]): plotter.add_mesh( pv.Spline(self.streamlines[i, :, :].T), color=p.adjust_lightness("#7700FF", 1.5), opacity=0.7, line_width=1 ) if show: plotter.show(**show_kwargs) return plotter else: raise ValueError("Bad value of `backend`!")
if __name__ == '__main__': ### Import Vanilla Airplane import aerosandbox as asb from pathlib import Path
[docs] geometry_folder = Path(__file__).parent / "test_aero_3D" / "geometries"
import sys sys.path.insert(0, str(geometry_folder)) from vanilla import airplane as vanilla ### Do the AVL run vlm = VortexLatticeMethod( airplane=vanilla, op_point=asb.OperatingPoint( atmosphere=asb.Atmosphere(altitude=0), velocity=10, alpha=0, beta=0, p=0, q=0, r=0, ), spanwise_resolution=12, chordwise_resolution=12, ) res = vlm.run() for k, v in res.items(): print(f"{str(k).rjust(10)} : {v}")